vintage holiday card: your input kindly requested

Right before the holidays last year, I created an illustrated vintage holiday card. I did not have enough time last year to have it printed, but this year I would like to print it as a flat note card and sell it in my Etsy shop. My thought is to sell it as a set and as individual cards.

But, before I can get it printed, I have to decide which colorway to go with. You see, I colored the illustration four different ways, and I have narrowed it down to two. Now, I must decide between the two - which colorway should the final card design be printed in!?

I am calling on YOU for input - which do you like better? Leave a comment below and let me know. Anyone who is kind enough to give me some feedback will receive one of the cards once they are printed!

Colorway #1 larger:

Colorway #2 larger:

My feeling is that #1 is more vintage-feeling and that is what I am going for, but obviously I want the design to be something that potential customers will like! 

What do you think?

(*If you leave a comment with your input below, also shoot me a quick email with your mailing address so that I can make good on my pledge and mail you one of the cards this holiday season once they are printed!)